About Skoolmakers
Skoolmakers is the independent comparison site for Skool communities. Here's how we work and why you can trust us.
๐ฏ Our Mission
The Skool ecosystem is growing fast, but it can be hard to navigate. Our mission is to help you find the Skool community that truly matches your goals, or to guide you in creating your own.
We test, analyze, and compare every community with the same rigor, whether the creator is a partner or not.
๐ Our Rating Methodology
Each standard listing is evaluated on 5 criteria, rated from 1 to 5. Communities we review from inside follow the rules below, under โHow we score in-depth reviewsโ.
Richness, freshness, format, and depth of courses and resources.
Member activity, creator responsiveness, daily interactions.
What you get relative to the price charged.
Background, credibility, and proven results of the creator.
Verifiable testimonials and concrete transformations.
The final score is a weighted average of these 5 criteria. We update scores regularly.
How we score in-depth reviews
An in-depth review is written from inside the community, as members. Its SkoolMakers score is a weighted average of five sub-scores, rounded to the tenth. Each sub-score comes from a dated count and fixed thresholds, so two people counting the same community get the same score.
| Sub-score | What we count | 5 | 4 | 3 | 2 | 1 |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Founder access 25% | Share of member questions where the creator takes part, on a sample of 150 or more (lives count under Value) | 50% or more | 35โ49% | 20โ34% | 10โ19% | under 10% |
| Content 25% | Course pages a member can open | 100 or more | 60โ99 | 30โ59 | 10โ29 | under 10 |
| Community 20% | Posts a day | 15 or more | 8โ14 | 3โ7 | 1โ2 | under 1 |
| Value 20% | Average of two half-scores: price against the paid median of the category, and lives with the creator | see below | ||||
| Access 10% | Share of courses open after about a week of normal participation, plus 0.5 with a refund | 85% or more | 65โ84% | 45โ64% | 25โ44% | under 25% |
Value averages two half-scores. The first compares the monthly price with the median price of the paid communities of the same category in our catalogue, computed at every build; free communities are left out of that median. At or under the median scores 5, up to 1.5 times scores 4, up to twice scores 3, up to three times scores 2, and more scores 1. The second counts live calls with the creator: at least one a week of 60 minutes or more scores 5, two or three a month scores 4, one a month scores 3, fewer scores 2, none scores 1.
- We do not score a return on investment. โOne tip pays for the monthโ is true of any paid group and cannot be measured, so it stays in the text.
- We do not reward a high price as a quality filter. We measure what the filter produces instead: expert answers and the creatorโs presence.
- Access does not penalise a lock by likes that normal participation opens in a few days. Paid add-ons and levels that take weeks of activity count as closed.
- The overall score is shown only when all five sub-scores are counted. Until then the review shows the lowest score still possible, with a โ+โ, and the range.
- An adjustment of half a point at most, up or down, is possible, with its reason written in the review.
- Risks get a level for each method taught, never a score.
- Skoolโs own star ratings are quoted as text. We never publish them as our rating.
๐ Transparency & Affiliations
Skoolmakers is partly funded through affiliate links. When you click on certain links and make a purchase, we may receive a commission, at no extra cost to you.
This does not affect our reviews in any way. We have declined partnerships with communities that we deemed below our standards. Our credibility is our most valuable asset.
โ ๏ธ Links marked "sponsored" or sign-up buttons are affiliate links. We always disclose this clearly.
Paid listings and advertising
Creators can pay for two things, and nothing else.
- Verified ($199) and In-depth review ($499), for 12 months. The creator confirms the facts on their page. For In-depth, we spend 14 days inside the community before writing a long review. These pages carry a "Verified by owner" badge and show no sponsored alternatives.
- Sponsored cards (Best page from $147, Spotlight from $497), for 30 days. A card on our most read pages, always labelled "Sponsored" and kept apart from the rankings.
What money cannot buy: a score, a rank, a verdict, or a softer list of cons. Paying and non-paying communities are rated with the same method.
Our editorial rules apply to paying communities, so no income or health promises. We can decline a community, and it is then refunded in full. A card that is not live on its start date is refunded in full. Nothing renews automatically.
โ๏ธ Contact Us
Have a question? Want to list your community? A review that needs correcting?
Contact us โ